Buy that special someone an AP Physics prep book, now with 180 five-minute quizzes aligned with the exam: 5 Steps to a 5 AP Physics 1

Visit Burrito Girl's handmade ceramics shop, The Muddy Rabbit: Yarn bowls, tea sets, dinner ware...

## 06 May 2014

### AP Atomic Energy Levels question: 2011 B6

Joseph Rao writes in to ask about AP Physics B question 6 on the 2011 exam.  (Can't post it, but follow the link.)  He notes:

The question said that an electron with KE of 4.8 eV can excite an electron in an atom upon collision even if the energy does not match the transitional energy from n=1 to n-=2. The energy difference between states was for 3 eV.

Huh... this confuzzled me momentarily, too.  I would've gotten it wrong on first attempt.

What makes this problem unusual is that it's an electron -- a massive particle -- causing the transition.

It's a PHOTON that can either be absorbed entirely or not.  There's no such thing as absorbing just some of a photon's energy.

However, an electron is a massive, classical particle, with speed that can vary.  It had 4.8 eV to begin with due to its 1.3 x 106 m/s speed.  Nothing wrong with the electron slowing down, giving some of its kinetic energy to the bound electron in the atom.  The bound electron jumps states by gaining 3.0 eV.  (The bound electron must absorb only the amount of energy necessary to jump states.)  The free electron goes on its merry way, now with (4.8 eV - 3.0 eV) = 1.8 eV of kinetic energy.  You can work out its speed to be smaller now.

GCJ

#### 1 comment:

1. I ran into the same problem this year! My top student and I just read it over and over scratching our heads. It's so easy to gloss over that first sentence sometimes!